Practical thermodynamics – the swimming pool, part 1
Marcin Polkowski
Translated from Polish. Originally published on morony.pl on 26 Jul 2009.
Part 1 of 2 in the series Garden pool physics
- Practical thermodynamics – the swimming pool, part 1
- The Stefan-Boltzmann swimming pool
How it started
I started thinking about the problem I'm about to describe roughly a month before the summer season began (it's already clear the season hasn't been much to write home about in terms of sunshine and temperatures – I'm still hoping it will warm up). In my backyard there's a collapsible above-ground pool. For this kind of construction it's very large: it holds as much as 30 cubic meters of water (7.5 * 3.5 * 1.15 meters).
As we all know (from observation / experience / school), water has a very high specific heat. In practice this means it takes a lot of energy to heat water, and that water cools down more slowly than its surroundings (the air). That fact is the source of the problem I want to consider.
The problem
Since I now know a few tricks (which I'll write about) when it comes to pool water temperature, I'll state the problem differently than I originally did. A few months ago I put it like this:
Find a method of effectively heating the water at minimal running cost
Today I'll state it like this:
Find a method of getting the water in the pool as warm as possible at minimal running cost
You might say there's not much difference between the two, but I do see one. At first my reasoning was purely theoretical, and I was looking for a way to heat the pool water. There were several options:
- Electric heating – a moderate cost for the equipment and an enormous running cost, given the amount of energy needed (heating the water once by 1 degree costs as much as 40 zloty)
- Heat pump – a high up-front cost and still a considerable running cost
- Solar panels – with pool panels (as opposed to the ones meant for home installations) the initial cost is relatively low and the running cost is zero. The downside is that they work only on sunny days and only for part of the day.
- Solid-fuel stove – heating the water with, say, wood. It turned out this needs quite an investment, and how well it would actually heat remained an unknown.
When it turned out that all these methods were expensive, I decided to approach the problem differently – more scientifically (this is where we move from heating to tricks). I thought about how energy is transported between the pool and the rest of the world. It's easy to guess that energy is transferred in several ways:
- Conduction and convection – these cause energy to flow in both directions, depending on how the water temperature compares with that of the surroundings. The amount of energy flowing is proportional to the temperature difference (water – surroundings). The proportionality constant includes, among other things, the active surface area and the type (conductivity) of the barrier between the water and the surroundings. We should also expect the energy flow to depend on additional parameters that are hard to predict and measure, such as wind speed or humidity, which affects the heat capacity of the air.
- Radiation – like conduction, it causes a positive or negative flow depending on the temperatures of the water and the surroundings. The size of this flow is proportional to the difference of the fourth powers of the temperatures. The proportionality constant mainly includes the active surface area and the absorptivity.
- Solar energy – responsible only for delivering heat (in the form of radiation) to the pool through all the sunlit surfaces. This is the largest of the energy sources considered. Unfortunately, predicting exactly how much energy the sun will deliver is very difficult because cloud cover varies.
- Evaporation – responsible only for the pool's loss of heat. It is a function of the water and air temperatures, humidity and wind. It is a quantity of great importance for the model and very difficult to estimate, because of its complicated dependence on parameters that change quickly and are hard to predict (wind).
For each of these flows it's hard to give concrete values because the problem is so complicated (lots of parameters that are hard to pin down). You can estimate. I expected radiation to cause a loss on the order of a few kilowatts at night, and convection to be less significant. The gain from the sun is also easy to estimate, since we know the pool's surface area and the amount of solar energy reaching each square meter (approximate values can be found in the literature). The biggest problem, though, is evaporation. I had (and still have) no idea how to calculate the amount of energy lost through evaporation. So I went to the Division of Environmental Physics at the Institute of Geophysics, University of Warsaw to ask whether they knew how to solve the evaporation problem. They confirmed my suspicion that it can't really be calculated, and suggested measuring it experimentally.
Even though we can't calculate exactly how much energy is lost to evaporation, we can estimate that it's larger than the losses through radiation and conduction. That gave me the idea of limiting evaporation. It can be done very simply: all you need to do is separate the water surface from the air with a sheet of plastic. Ordinary plastic sheeting would sink after the first rain, so I used bubble wrap, which floats on the water and effectively eliminates evaporation.
After this, the water temperature rose by several degrees compared with an uncovered pool. Three hot days in a row were enough to warm the water up to a pleasant 29 degrees.
I didn't stop there, though. The next step, which I haven't done yet, is to calculate the actual energy losses and gains from measurements. I already have an extensive set of experimental data (the measurement setup itself deserves a separate article) – water temperature and air temperature. Now I want to use this data to work out how the heat loss at night (without the sun) depends on the temperature difference: with and without evaporation. Once I know these values, I may be able to simulate economical heating.
As soon as I've processed the experimental data, I'll share my conclusions with you in another post.
Next in Garden pool physics: The Stefan-Boltzmann swimming pool →